Growing up with Santa AND Jesus can be difficult. With this being my first year as a Christ follower (not just a believer), I’ve been delighting in the wonderful Christmas story! However, I have been comparing the amazing truth of Jesus’s birth to what I knew and thought about Santa Claus. There are some serious differences in these two conflicting messages that I have realized!
Think about this song we sing about Santa Claus.
“He knows when you are sleeping, he knows when you’re awake. He knows if you’ve been bad or good, so be good for goodness sake. You better watch out, you’d better not cry, you better not pout, I’m telling you why. Santa Claus is coming to town.”
We are introduced to an omniscient being who knows what everything we do! For those children who believe in God, too, it is easy to compare the two beings right away. It is especially difficult because we celebrate these two beings at the same time each year! Santa, who sees all and judges us for right or wrong. And God, who… does he do that, too?
For most of my life, I thought that God, like Santa, was judging me. Keeping track of my errors and wrongdoings. Marking them down on a list. Labeling us as “naughty” or “nice.” This misconception confused me as a child, giving me the impression that our all-knowing God was keeping track the way that Santa did, and I should behave because I knew that God, and Santa, was watching.
So why do we need to behave for Santa? Well, as the tale goes, when we are “nice” we receive the gifts that we asked for! But when we are “naughty,” all that we receive is coal! We get the impression that what we get is based off of what we do.
Once again, many children are surrounded by the word of God during Christmastime, and also the presence of Santa. So I can see why this is a common thought about our God, too. If we act kindly, do the right thing, and follow his word, we will receive blessings, happiness, and wealth. If we sin and do wrong, will we face troubles and hardships (and receive coal)? The answer is no! Our experiences are not given to us by God based upon what we do. Instead, we may be given blessings or hardships by a God who has a greater plan for us. We need to respond with faith and trust in the Lord’s control of our lives, knowing that what we are given might feel unfair at times!
This is much more complex than the ideas in our minds about Santa Claus. It is easy to think that we are given good things for doing good, and bad things for acting badly. However, God is much bigger than this. His plan is beyond our comprehension and cannot be conceived or predicted by us.
Finally, the most important message of all, the message from our God, gives us a much greater gift than the ones we receive from Santa. Children delight in the gifts on Christmas morning left by a wonderful, giving man! He gives us what we ask for (after earning it by being good all year) and we rejoice. Yet, there is a greater gift from God.
The gift from God is given to all. Gifts from Santa are given to those who can afford it.
The gift from God is given freely. Gifts from Santa are (supposedly) given to those who “earned” it by being good.
The gift from God is eternal. We receive it once and for all. The gifts from Santa are often used for a few months before forgotten about next to a new, more exciting present.
Nothing is more exciting than the gift from God of freedom and redemption!
The gift from God erases our sins and wrongdoings. He knows that we will continue to make mistakes as sinful humans, but the gift of his son cleans us! Santa judges us for errors with his list, not knowing that by the gift of Christmas has set us free from the never-ending list of our sins.
There is one very important similarity between the concept of Santa and our Savior’s birth. On Christmas morning, as kids, we run downstairs to a great gift beneath the tree given to us by Santa. It is waiting for us to open it! To celebrate it and delight in it! Every day, there is a gift from God, just waiting for us to receive it. A gift of forgiveness, love, acceptance, and freedom. A gift of a son, sent to die the death that WE deserve for our sin and error! A gift that is waiting beneath a tree (the cross). Let us RUN to this gift and accept what the Lord has freely given us, with the same joy and excitement as a child on Christmas morning.